L. A. White and S. Prentice
Summary: there are robust policy reasons for implementing full-day
kindergarten, but it should designed as one element in a broader early years
strategy.
Three facts to know:
1. Currently, BC, Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, New
Brunswick, and PEI fund and deliver full-day kindergarten (FDK) through public
schools, and other jurisdictions are considering or are in the process of adopting
the policy. FDK is presented as a way to support children’s early years in a
context of the changing family.
2. Widespread enthusiasm for FDK as the sole policy
instrument to meet the needs of the early years is counter-intuitive both
because FDK is more expensive to deliver than tax breaks or subsidizing
parents’ child care expenses, and because there is also good evidence supporting
other early childhood development programs, including childcare services.
3. Public administration scholars fiercely debate whether or
how much evidence and expert opinion really matters in how governments make
decisions: looking at the wave of FDK adoption in Canada provides empirical
evidence about how both were used.
Three myths or misconceptions to dispel:
1. FDK was usually adopted as a consequence of an expert
commission/panel that recommended changes, citing child development arguments
that were presented as evidence-based, yet would be considered narrow by
academic standards. A broad consideration that holistically addressed early
childhood care and education seemed beyond the reach of most expert actors.
2. Governments rarely fully implement the programs
recommended even by their own experts. Political remedies appeared restricted
to possibilities easily incorporated into provincial education mandates.
3. In the case of FDK, policy change was driven by highly selective
path dependency that used evidence to justify predetermined policy preferences.
FDK seems to be the contemporary provincial government “hammer” for every “nail”
of family policy (child development, socio-economic disadvantage, parental
labor market participation, and economic competitiveness).
White, L. A. and S. Prentice (2016). “Early Childhood
Education and Care Reform in Canadian Provinces: Understanding the Role of
Experts and Evidence in Policy Change.” Canadian Public Administration 59: 26 -
44.